Are Gay Men Our Oppressors, Too?

By

 

I was so fortunate to attend the unveiling ceremony for a sign on East 68th Street in Manhattan marking the new "Audre Lorde Way" on May 10th. Writers and dignitaries were present to praise the event and Lorde herself, including the president of Hunter College (from which Lorde graduated in 1959, and where she served as a professor for many years), NYC Council Member Keith Powers, former National Ambassador for Young People's Literature and MacArthur Fellow Jacqueline Woodson, and others. To end the program before the actual unveiling of the street sign, several Hunter students came to the stage to read Lorde's essay "There is No Hierarchy of Oppressions," which, of course, got me thinking.



I had just recently attended the GLAAD Media Awards a few days before, and had been struck by the numbers of drag queens, trans women performers, and gay men who walked the red carpet, as opposed to the comparatively small number of lesbians. GLAAD stands for the Gay AND LESBIAN Alliance Against Defamation, so why are so few lesbians being recognized by this organization?

Gay men's lack of interest in lesbians was recently parodied in a Saturday Night Live skit in which a fragment of the writings of Sappho was translated as reading, "Why don't gay guys invite us to their events?" It was a hilarious moment, but it is no laughing matter when it comes to the financial disparities between gay men and lesbians.

Kate McKinnon and Ariana DeBose

I was totally out of my comfort zone when I asked to walk the red carpet as a Lambda Literary Award Finalist. It is not in my nature to demand attention and shout "Look at me! Look at ME!!" But this is exactly what it takes to be a drag queen. Typically, drag queens represent a small percentage of the LGBTQ+ community. But you wouldn't know it judging from the red carpet arrivals.


Gay male organizers need to be sensitive to the fact that lesbians might not be as pushy as some of the gay men and drag performers whom they're used to dealing with, since testosterone is not coursing through our veins. Now that war is constantly in the news, it feels like testosterone has run amok globally. Vladimir Putin has enabled his military men to rape and murder innocent civilians, and nothing or no one can stop him it seems. Billions of dollars have been pledged by our own president to be spent on weapons to help Ukraine, while women and children starve in our own country. And now the Supreme Court of the United States is threatening to take away a woman's right to choose.

Men have blamed women for their own impotence since time immemorial. It was the same during slavery when white slave owners blamed the slaves for their impotence, instead of examining the effects of alcoholism on their bodies. This brings me back to the words of Audre Lorde:

"I have learned that sexism and heterosexism
both arise from the same source as racism."

                                                                               - Audre Lorde 


One can safely say that the majority of women have not been socialized to go out there and get what they want. Most women have been taught to sit back and wait for life to happen to them. That was certainly the case for my upbringing. Being aggressive was considered unfeminine and unattractive. After my graduation from Juilliard, it soon became clear that sitting and waiting was not going to result in any kind of success.

I know full well what it means to not be hired for certain gigs or engagements for no other reason than the fact that I was black. I also know what it means to not be hired because I'm a woman. The results are the same: no income, and economic powerlessness.

This brings me back to economic disparity. Men are able to afford expensive real estate, luxury vacations, membership in private clubs, etc. - because of their superior income as men - in a way that most lesbians are not. Heterosexual women, by virtue of their financial association with men, are economically privileged in a way that lesbians are not. Combine that with the economic deprivation that blackness brings to the table, and you have a recipe for disaster.

Even a lesbian icon like Audre Lorde felt the pressure to marry and have children in the 1960s. And her husband was a white man.


We all know that black women were the nurses and the ones cleaning out the hospital rooms during the COVID-19 pandemic, and a significant number of them were lesbians. We all know that black women were dying in disproportionate numbers during the pandemic.

Now that the U.S. Supreme Court - with its three Trump appointees - is poised to overturn Roe v. Wade, though it isn't technically my issue, I will stand side-by-side with my sisters of child-bearing age to fight for their right to choose. All of us will need to stand as a united front when they come for us and our rights. It is only a matter of time.

The right wingers don't care about women having more babies. The point is to take a woman's power away, to force her into poverty so that she'll take menial jobs and submit to the whims of husbands, fathers, and boyfriends. Any man who needs a woman to be subservient in order to feel like a man is not a man. He will never be a man as long as he looks to someone else to prop him up.

Brittney Griner
I can understand how some men who may have been raised by domineering mothers might have a hard time seeing women as being oppressed. But the fact remains that women make only 82 cents for every dollar a man makes for the same job. WNBA star and out lesbian Brittney Griner is trapped in Russia right now because she was trying to make some extra money in the off-season by playing in Russia. WNBA players make less than ten per cent of what male players in the NBA make.

I am hoping that my white gay male brothers will take heed and notice when their organizations are disproportionately white and male. We may not kick the door down, but trust and believe that we are standing outside hoping to be invited in.






Nina Kennedy is a concert pianist, orchestral conductor, and award-winning filmmaker. She holds a master’s degree from the Juilliard School. Her memoir, "Practicing for Love," is a 2021 Lambda Literary Award Finalist.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reflections on an Unforgettable Pride Month

By
Image
The month of June began for me with the announcement that I had been selected by Crain's New York to appear on their list of Notable LGBTQIA+ Business Leaders for 2023. I was humbled by and grateful for the honor, and thrilled that the notoriety would help to promote my production company INFEMNITY Productions LLC . Soon afterwards, an invitation appeared in my Inbox to attend New York City Mayor Eric Adams' Pride Reception at Gracie Mansion. It was my first opportunity to meet the mayor, and to inform him of my being a recipient of the Crain's New York Award. On the same day as the mayor's Pride Reception, our favorite bartender at the Cubbyhole, Kass, presented me with the Crain's New York trophy. Many of the patrons at the Cubbyhole that night might not have known that Crain's New York publishes a list of Notable LGBTQIA+ Business Leaders. Having the award presentation there was my way of bringing the news to the community, and, of course, giving a shout-ou...
Read more

Lisa Durden and the Burden of the False Angry Black Woman Narrative

By
Image
The black person’s burden of managing white fragility is as old as slavery. Dr. Joy DeGruy speaks of this in her groundbreaking book, Post Traumatic Slave Syndrome . There is a delicate balance between the comfort of maintaining a superior cast system and the guilt of protecting it. And still today, people vastly underestimate the extent to which black lives are filled with a level of racial stress that most white people are not exposed to and simply couldn’t deal with. Lisa Durden, a talk show host, pop-culture commentator, film curator and adjunct professor, went on Fox News to discuss the New York City Black Lives Matter chapter’s Memorial Day party, where they asked that if people did not identify as part of the African Diaspora, that they not attend. Durden went head-to-head with Tucker Carlson to explain why she supported the New York City Black Lives Matter chapter’s decision. Durden argued that as Memorial Day was founded by disenfranchised blacks, and as blacks continue to ...
Read more

Jon Batiste at Cooper Union

By
Image
  Written for presentation at the Juilliard Black Alumni Association Inaugural Mixer Lincoln Center, September 9, 2023 A few weeks ago I saw an announcement of a special performance by pianist Jon Batiste at The Cooper Union Great Hall. I jumped at the chance because I wanted to present him with a copy of my memoir titled Practicing for Love . I, too, am a Juilliard grad, and my father was one of the first African-American pianists to study at Juilliard. He and Leontyne Price were classmates. He then went on to direct the Fisk Jubilee Singers. Of course, all of that history was included in the book. I stood in line for the performance, which was advertised as “A Musical Prescription,” and was co-sponsored by the Louis Armstrong Center for Music and Medicine at Mount Sinai Health System’s Assessment of Music Experiences in Navigating Depression (AMEND Lab) and Carnegie Hall’s Weill Music Institute, the Hall’s education and social impact arm. The event began half an hour late, and th...
Read more

2023 Out Leadership OutNEXT Global Summit

By
Image
  Citi Global Headquarters in New York City was the location for the 2023 Out Leadership OutNEXT   Global Summit September 27 and 28, co-sponsored by RBC Capital Markets . To quote their website: " Out Leadership  is the global LGBTQ+ business platform CEOs and multinational companies trust to generate Return on Equality®." Hundreds of young professionals from eleven countries came to the summit that consisted of two days of panel discussions, fireside chats, lunches and cocktail receptions for LGBTQ+ leaders in business, finance, law, and the arts. Mila Jam Recording artist and Senior Advisor for Global Transgender Initiatives for Out Leadership Mila Jam  emceed, and Out Leadership CEO Todd Sears   welcomed the participants. Our own Nina Kennedy   served as a panelist for the opening session titled "Using Your Identity to Build a Meaningful Career." Other panels included "Mentorship & Sponsorship," "Advocacy & Impact," "Building a P...
Read more

INFEMNITY Productions at World Press Freedom Day

By
Image
Several venues in New York hosted events in celebration of World Press Freedom Day during the week of May 1st through 5th, the most notable being the United Nations. The result of the Windhoek Declaration, which was produced at a UNESCO seminar "Promoting an Independent and Pluralistic African Press" - held in Windhoek, the capital of Namibia, from April 29th to May 3rd 1991 - t he date of the Declaration's adoption, May 3rd, has subsequently been declared as World Press Freedom Day. This year marked the 30th anniversary of the global conference. This year, the primary focus of the conference was the war in Ukraine. Several journalists have lost their lives there. The documentary 20 Days in Mariupol was screened at the Roosevelt House at Hunter College the evening of May 1st, which emphasized the importance of getting video footage out of a war zone when Internet access has been destroyed. The producers of the film came very close to losing their lives, as well as their ...
Read more

In Case You Haven't Noticed, Women Are Under Attack

By
Image
As the Supreme Court inches toward overturning Roe v. Wade, the likelihood increases that a young American woman will no longer have any control over whether or not she will carry a pregnancy to term. Her education and her career may be interrupted, her financial status and security put in peril. It seems white men are longing for a romanticized fantasy of the good ole days when they had all the power, and women were totally dependent on them. Well, they are creating a scenario where women will have to refuse to engage with them sexually. If the Supreme Court has its way, even a child conceived from rape and/or incest will have to be carried to term.  According to the World Health Organization, about 295,000 women died during and following pregnancy and childbirth in 2017. The Supreme Court This represents a nightmare for future generations. It is no surprise that Donald Trump, a rapist himself, has appointed Supreme Court Justices who are invested in taking away women's freedom. T...
Read more

How State and Local Governments Impoverish African-American Neighborhoods

By
Image
This article was written to recount my first-hand experience with the heartbreak of American racism. Soon after my father’s death I learned that I was the owner of a house in Charleston, West Virginia, which had been built by my grandfather, Dr. Henry Floyd Gamble, who was one of the first African-American graduates of the Yale Medical School. He set up a practice in Charleston as the first African-American surgeon, obstetrician, and gynecologist in the region, and founded the local chapter of the National Medical Association – the African-American version of the American Medical Association since the AMA did not accept African-Americans as members. He resided in the home he built with my grandmother and his four offspring, two of whom were adults by the time he and my grandmother married. When he died, he bequeathed the property to three of his children: my aunt Katherine, my uncle Howard, and my mother. Upon my mother’s death, her portion of the property went to my father; and upon ...
Read more

White Supremacists Storm the U.S. Capitol

By
Image
   January 6, 2021: Egged on by Donald Trump, white supremacists penetrate the Capitol Building shouting "Hang Mike Pence," and "Where's Nancy?", destroying property and stealing from offices of members of Congress. Rioters included retired and current members of law enforcement. It is no surprise to African Americans that white supremacists have infiltrated law enforcement. Ask anyone who has followed the Black Lives Matter movement and is familiar with the countless murders of unarmed black men by police. But now that "Trumpets" have attacked the Capitol, and it has been discovered that many of the white men in the mob were either retired or current members of law enforcement, white people are shocked. It has been reported that white supremacist congressmen Andy Biggs, Mo Brooks, and Paul Gosar assisted some of the rioters in planning their attack. It has also been reported that white supremacist members of Congress took rioters on tours of the Capit...
Read more

Hetrick-Martin Institute Honors Monica Lewinsky

By
Image
  The annual Emery Awards benefitting the Hetrick-Martin Institute took place last Thursday, November 16th, at the Mercedes Benz showroom on the West Side of Manhattan. The school for LGBTQ+ youth raised lots of money via silent and public auctions, pledges, and donations. Guest of honor Monica Lewinsky was introduced to receive her award by Rufus Gifford, Finance Chair for Biden-Harris ‘24. When Monica took the stage, she received a standing ovation. She gave a moving speech affirming her status as an LGBTQ+ ally, and spoke of understanding the kind of shame that LGBTQ+ youth live with. She, herself, lived with enormous shame while she coped with the aftermath of her affair with President Bill Clinton. She became the butt of jokes on late-night television, struggled with depression and thoughts of suicide, and was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder. At the time of the scandal, Monica Lewinsky was arguably the most famous woman in the world. And what was s...
Read more